Quaker Windows vs Andersen Windows: Which is the Best Choice for Your Home?

Todd Gillman

December 17,2023

Todd Gillman, the Building Product Advisor Editor specializing in Branding & Company Reviews, thrives on sharing his wealth of knowledge in construction and building trends. His valuable contributions can be explored on Building Product Advisor, where Todd plays a pivotal role in educating readers through comprehensive branding insights and meticulous company and product reviews.

Windows are crucial for maintaining comfort, conserving energy, and enhancing the visual charm of your residence. The market offers a wide array of brands and materials, making the selection process quite challenging. This article strives to guide you in making a well-informed choice by examining two renowned brands: Quaker Windows and Andersen Windows.

Photo courtesy of https://www.quakerresidentialwindows.com/product/cityvu-picture-window/

Different Types of Windows in the Marketplace

Wood Windows 

Recognized for their natural elegance and insulating characteristics, wood windows appeal to numerous homeowners. Easily tailored to complement your home's style, they come in a variety of designs and finishes. However, consistent maintenance is necessary to avoid decay, distortion, and insect infestation.

Vinyl Windows

As an affordable and low-maintenance alternative, vinyl windows enjoy widespread popularity. They offer decent insulation and moisture resistance, making them well-suited for damp or humid environments. Nevertheless, their appearance might be less appealing compared to other materials, and they cannot be painted or stained.

Aluminum Windows 

Robust and lightweight, aluminum windows serve as a superb choice for modern and contemporary residences. With minimal upkeep, they resist rust and corrosion while providing enhanced security. Yet, aluminum's insulating properties are subpar, leading to potential heat loss or gain.

Wood Clad Windows 

Combining the beauty of wood with the durability of another material (usually aluminum or vinyl), wood-clad windows offer the best of both worlds. They require less maintenance than traditional wood windows and provide better insulation.

Composite Windows 

Made from a combination of materials, composite windows are designed to offer the benefits of multiple materials without their downsides. They typically require low maintenance and offer excellent energy efficiency, durability, and aesthetics.

Quaker Windows

Photo courtesy of https://www.quakerresidentialwindows.com/inspiration-gallery/

Quaker Windows is a well-respected manufacturer known for its high-quality products and diverse range of window materials and styles. Their products cater to both new construction and replacement markets.

  1. Wood Windows: Quaker Windows offers wood windows in various styles, including casement, double-hung, and sliding windows. These windows are praised for their craftsmanship and aesthetics, but they require regular maintenance to ensure longevity.
  2. Vinyl Windows: Quaker Windows offers an assortment of vinyl windows for both new builds and retrofit projects. These windows present a budget-friendly and energy-saving choice, but their aesthetics might not be as attractive as wood or composite alternatives.
  3. Aluminum Windows: The firm's aluminum windows are sturdy and require minimal upkeep, making them fitting for contemporary residences. Although they may not be the most energy-efficient option, they are still a viable choice.
  4. Wood Clad Windows: Quaker Windows offers wood-clad windows as well, which combine the aesthetic appeal of wood with the resilience of other materials, giving homeowners the best of both worlds. These windows have better insulation and require less maintenance than traditional wood windows.

Top Reasons to Buy Quaker Windows

There are several reasons why you might choose Quaker Windows over Andersen Windows when making a decision for your home:

Material Variety

Quaker Windows offers a broader range of materials compared to Andersen Windows. While both companies provide wood and vinyl windows, Quaker Windows also includes aluminum windows in their product lineup, offering more options for homeowners with specific preferences.

Budget-Friendly Options

Quaker Windows' vinyl windows are considered cost-effective options for homeowners who are budget-conscious. While Andersen Windows' 100 Series Fibrex® windows are energy-efficient and visually appealing, they may be more expensive than traditional vinyl windows.

Personal Preferences

Some homeowners may have a personal preference for the design or style of Quaker Windows products over those of Andersen Windows. It is essential to consider individual tastes and the aesthetics of one's home when choosing between the two brands.

Andersen Windows

Photo courtesy of https://www.andersenhomedepot.com/series/400-series/

Andersen Windows is a well-established window manufacturer with a reputation for producing high-quality, energy-efficient windows. They offer a variety of window materials and styles suitable for both new construction and replacement markets.

  1. Wood Windows: Andersen Windows' wood windows are known for their durability, aesthetics, and energy efficiency. There are different styles of wood windows available like casement, double-hung, and awning. But similar to other wood windows, they need to be maintained regularly to maintain their appearance and functionality.
  2. Vinyl Windows: Andersen Windows offers vinyl windows as part of their 100 Series product line. These windows are constructed using a material called Fibrex®, which blends the advantages of wood and vinyl. The Fibrex® windows are visually attractive as well as energy-efficient and require less maintenance. However, the cost of Fibrex® windows might be higher compared to standard vinyl windows.
  3. Aluminum Windows: Andersen Windows does not currently offer aluminum windows in their product lineup.
  4. Wood Clad Windows: Andersen Windows provides wood-clad windows made with their patented Fibrex® material. These windows have the appearance of wood with the added benefits of improved durability, insulation, and reduced maintenance.
  5. Composite Windows: Andersen Windows is known for its composite windows, specifically their Fibrex® material. These windows offer excellent energy efficiency, durability, and aesthetics, making them a popular choice for many homeowners.
  6. Screen Doors and Storm Doors: Storm and screen doors are an affordable and easy way to improve your home. They offer many benefits such as energy efficiency, improved appearance, better ventilation, and added protection.

Top Reasons to Buy Andersen Windows

You may prefer Andersen Windows over Quaker Windows for various reasons:

Innovative Materials

Andersen Windows is known for its innovative Fibrex® composite material, which combines the benefits of wood and vinyl. Fibrex® windows offer excellent energy efficiency, durability, and aesthetics, making them an attractive choice for many homeowners.

Wood Clad and Composite Windows

Andersen Windows provides wood-clad windows made with their patented Fibrex® material, which has the appearance of wood but offers improved durability, insulation, and reduced maintenance requirements. This may appeal to homeowners who desire the beauty of wood without its maintenance challenges.


Andersen Windows is a well-established window manufacturer with a strong reputation for producing high-quality, energy-efficient windows. Their commitment to innovation and quality may instill confidence in homeowners who are looking for a reliable brand.

Customer Service

Andersen Windows is known for its excellent customer service, which can be an important factor for homeowners who require support during the purchasing, installation, or warranty process.

Warranties and Availability

Photo courtesy of https://www.andersenwindows.com/ideas-and-inspiration/photo-gallery/
  • Quaker Windows offers a limited lifetime warranty on their vinyl windows, covering defects in material and workmanship. The warranty duration for other materials may vary. It is essential to read the warranty terms and conditions carefully and register your products upon installation.
  • Andersen Windows provides a 20-year limited warranty on glass and a 10-year limited warranty on non-glass components for their wood windows. Their 100 Series Fibrex® windows come with a 10-year limited warranty on glass and a 20-year limited warranty on non-glass components.

Both companies have nationwide availability, with authorized dealers and installers across the United States. This ensures that homeowners can access their products and services regardless of their location. You can find local dealers and installers through the companies' websites: Quaker Windows and Andersen Windows.

Comparing Quaker Windows and Andersen Windows: Factors to Consider

Both Quaker Windows and Andersen Windows offer a diverse range of high-quality window materials and styles to suit various preferences and budgets. When choosing the best option for your home, it is crucial to weigh the pros and cons of each brand, including material variety, energy efficiency, aesthetics, durability, and cost. Additionally, consider each company's warranty and availability across the country.

Get Smarter About Building Products

Join 50,000+ subscribers and get our 3 min daily newsletter on what matters in the building materials industry.

    You might like this